AMZ - November, 1998 - Knapsack
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
 
 
Vol 2 Number 12

  November, 1998

 
 

     
 

 
Artist: Knapsack
Title: "This Conversation is Ending Starting Right Now"
Label: Arista Records
Reviewed By: G.E. Sciacca
Rating:
   

Continuing a tradition of intelligent, aggressive and beautifully tortured power pop/punk music, "Knapsack" brings forth their third major release, "This Conversation Is Ending Starting Right Now." Considerably more tight and polished than previous releases, "Knapsack" has managed to maintain the raw emotional power that has been the drive of their sound, while bringing the music to a higher level of production and presentation. This third release marks the band's greatest effort thus far, marking a trend of progression to perfection.

Tracks like "Katherine The Grateful" and "Arrows to Action" take the form of polished versions of songs that could have easily been on either of the first two records. "Change Is All The Rage" introduces the use of sounds and additions outside the realm of guitar, bass and drums, creating a more interesting "Knapsack" sound.

Taking a bit of a departure from their "standard" anguished soul distortion sound, "Cold Enough To Break" stands out as a truly unique addition to the "Knapsack" song book, taking a quieter, and even prettier, approach with the addition of cello and sleigh bells enhancing an extremely deep introspective effort.

With the addition of Sergie Loobkoff (former Samiam) on guitar, "Knapsack" also finds a more concentrated, fuller sound. Sergie maintains the perfect simplicity in guitar style but adds several short solo flairs not previously present in former works.

Blair Shehan's vocals are as gut wrenchingly tortured as ever, overflowing with emotion and power. Lyrically, "Knapsack" remains the educated mans punk, while at the same time reaching into your chest and tearing out your heart with it's tearfully painful beauty.

"This Conversation..." is by far more then just "Knapsack's" most impressive effort to date, it's one of the most impressive records of this year. To not own it is to deprive yourself an amazing experience.

Access To The Music Zone was able to catch Blair Shehan for a few words at NYC Tramps earlier this month. Here's what he had to say:

 

AMZ - Congratulations on "This Conversation Is Ending Starting Right Now." This marks the third fantastic release from "Knapsack." I think this is your best work yet.

BS: - Thanks very much. I'm glad you're into it.

AMZ: - Unique album titles have become a tradition for "Knapsack." Where do the titles come from, and more specifically, where did "This Conversation . . ." come from?

BS - Okay. "Selfish Sweepstakes" is sort of a nothing title. It's kind of sort of random - you know, like when you just land on something? "Day Three of My New Life" was sort of written at a really tough point in my life, and all the songs on that record were sort of like a summing up of the whole record. "Day Three of My New Life" is "Hey, I'm gonna start new today." Having the best intentions of doing the new thing. Changing the bad things in your life and the stupid things you do. The third day is the day when its like you sort of get back into the old thing. It's like the day when you are weak, it's the day when you're not feeling that the fight is sort of out of you. "This Conversation ..." was written in a little better time in my life, and its a little bit of a light title I guess. I just like the way it sounds and it was the chorus of a song. It sounds like something you've heard, but haven't heard, you know? I liked the idea of maybe trying to coin a phrase, so we just stuck with it and I liked it.

AMZ: - Production on "This Conversation . . ." is considerably tighter and more polished than on earlier records. Was that a result of a conscience decision by Alex Newport, or the band, or both?

BS: - On the first record we were really just this rough band, on the second record it was like let's get our sound so that it sounds good on record. But I played all the guitar on the first record, and sang, and all the songs were written with me playing and singing at the same time. So everything is a lot looser and lot more straight forward and a lot simpler. The newer record has another guitar player playing, and when I play now I just mute the guitar I sing. Someone else is playing, and they can concentrate and be tight, where if I'm playing I have to play along with my singing so I can't really do that.

AMZ - So it's more performance than production.

BS - Exactly. It's more of a way to divide up the job.

AMZ - Your sound has always remained progressive and experimental, and there has always been that signature continuity from song to song. That's something that a lot of bands have a hard time with - progressing into a new sound while keeping that signature sound. Is there anything in particular you do to maintain that, or does it just kind of happen?

BS - We try not to do anything like that. I don't want to change. If I AM gonna change, I'm gonna change drastically, but if we're gonna be this band we're gonna stay similar but grow, expand on the idea. We always try to keep the root there, but move out with other stuff. Throwing in something extra makes it be not quite what we normally do, but we give it a shot, and see how it works, and that's how you make what you do uniquely yours. If I was gonna do something that completely different, it would not even be similar.

AMZ - "This Conversation . . ." leans more toward a poppier sound, or the poppier side of the spectrum, than the old records did. Is that a general direction the band is going in, or just for this record?

BS - I would say that the second record was a little darker and more aggressive. The new record has a lot of thick moments that are the same, but there are more quiet moments, more pop. I guess it's never conscious, you just do it. You write these songs and it's it sort of reflects where we were at in our lives.

AMZ - Your bio brings up the struggle with being pigeon holed. Do you guys see yourself fitting into any musical genre, or are you just being yourselves and where ever it falls, it falls?

BS - We're a guitar rock band and are given all sorts of little tags all along the way. It's nice if people associate us with something, because being associated with nothing when you're a smaller band like we are is difficult. No one has any reference to my performance. If you just see "Knapsack" it's like "Oh, what is that?" But if they read "Knapsack" is this type of band, it can be really helpful. So its a curse and a blessing at the same time. I'm not gonna complain, because its really like any time you are pigeon holed. People who like you know what you do. Writers and reviewers don't know what you do, and don't know the subtleties of what you do, are gonna be generic in the way they describe you. "Knapsack" is kinda like "blah, blah this," and people that really like you already know and like what you do, regardless of what somebody writes.

AMZ - The song writing process, is that collective or an individual effort?

BS - On this new record, more so than the last record, Sergie has a stronger presence, because he had written music in his other bands, so I let a little slack go and I try to focus more on my lyrics and things like that. I wrote the book of the songs, but nine out of the ten songs Sergie wrote brought in different rhythmic things that change the style a little bit, and I couldn't do that. Like I said earlier with playing, he plays what he plays his own way, so when I'm singing, and he's playing, he's gonna play differently than I play. It changed things just by his own flare, and he has lead skills that I don't really have.

AMZ - So what influenced some of those dark topics?

BS - A big thing is weakness. It's like being weak and hoping that you're not falling short on things. It's like we have the best intentions in the world - I'm gonna do this and I'm gonna do that . . . For example, I'm gonna really say thank you to that person, write them this little letter, put a little card in, then the day slips by and you don't do it. That sort of thing is like this weakness that you have where you don't follow through with things, and with me personally that was a big problem. For me this was like coming to terms with growing up and being adult, but still having the same kid being a slacker. Not finishing things, not taking care of the shit I had to take care of, not being grown up about taking control of my life, and that was a big coming of age sort of thing. I finished college, college gave me the guidelines to do stuff. I can do THAT stuff. Give me something to do and I'll do it - write a term paper, take the test, whatever, and I will finish college. But when I am on my own, that's a whole different story. That was when a lot of these records were written - when I was out on my own and doing stuff I didn't know exactly how to take care of.

AMZ - There's been a bunch of up and coming bands that you guys have been an inspiration to, that look up to you. Who are some of the bands that you have been inspired by?

BS - I like a lot of different kinds of bands. I like bands that sound like us sometime, I like bands that don't sound like us. I like a lot of just big commercial bands too - Weezer, Radio Head stuff like that. Those bands are fun. I usually enjoy big rock sort of bands a lot of the time. For quiet stuff I like classic song writing - like Beatles or James Taylor or Jim Croce and stuff like that. I really like songs, and I hope that I wean enough rough edges off what I do, so that I ultimately write songs that when we're not playing them they float around somewhere.

AMZ - Taking into consideration all the records, "Silver Sweepstakes," "Day Three," the Seven Inches and "This Conversation . . ." which would you say is the career piece thus far? Your best record?

BS - You know it's weird. In some ways it's the new one, and in some ways the second one. The second one was the one where we got attention. The first one we were nobody. With the second one, it was like slowly but surely this one built up on a small underground scale. By no means are we a big popular band, but that record was the one that sort of got people interested in our band. With the new record we expanded on stuff. I imagine that people will think our second record is the one that is the definitive record, but every band has to keep moving on and doing different things, and that was the one that sort of defined what we can and can't do. The newer records are more what we are into and where we're at right now.

AMZ - What are your expectations for this record, the one you just released?

BS - I have no idea. I hope people like it and people buy it and we have a good time on tour. Expectations are ridiculous because you just don't know where it's gonna go. Our contract is over with Alias, and we're free to go, so I hope that we can draw enough attention to get on a new label.

AMZ - So you're looking to leave Alias?

BS - We're not looking to leave, we're already off. It's over. We need a new label if we're gonna continue. We're a band that is slow in the studio, and we've been spending a lot of money. We can't make records, I mean we could but I wouldn't want to, that are really cheap, so we're sort of in the middle of no man's land, but we do stuff like that.

AMZ - "Cold Enough To Break" represents the biggest departure from the typical "Knapsack" sound. What makes this song different from the others, and what made you look toward a softer sound on that?

BS - You know it's just a difference between the distortion pedal. We play these songs, and if I'm gonna get choked up or be moved when we play, that's usually the one that does it to me. It's just a desperate sounding song. I don't think there is any departure or anything. It's just something that is able to move me more than any big rock sound could.

AMZ - The use of sleigh bells on that song, what brought that on?

BS - (laughs) Probably "OK Computer," the new Radio Head record. They had all these cool sounds and these isolated things. It sounds so random but you know they worked really hard to get those things in there. We heard that stuff and were just really into trying to add that to our record, because it makes it really interesting when you slap on the head phones and hear that.

AMZ - So the same can be said for the cello and other additions?

BS - Exactly. You want to put that stuff on there because it makes it more interesting.

AMZ - "Cinema Stare" reminds me of a more 80's Cure sound. Were you striving for that on this track?

BS - It's totally different - like pop, off-timing stuff. Somebody told me it was in waltz timing. It was just one of those songs that I brought in as a guitar part and we all fleshed it out. When I play guitar and sing at home, I try to trap everything I do. I keep a tape recording so I don't loose it. That's really how that song got it's start. Then the rest of the band helped bring it together.

AMZ - This new record seems a bit more upbeat, or happier, than the earlier ones. Was that more of a conscious effort, or was it that the sun is shining a little brighter these days?

BS - (laughs) Yeah, things are definitely better in my life. Well, yes and no. But when we did our second record I was in a really desperate "Didn't know my way out" place, so to me that record is a really dark desperate record. On this new one there's a little more light, but some of that dark is still there. My work totally reflects where I'm at any given time. I'm also a dark person. I like the darker side of things.

AMZ - "This Conversation . . .," and even the last record, have that really interesting kind of cartoon style on them. Where do you get the cover art ideas?

BS - The second record was awesome. I love that artwork. This guy, Alvin Yetz, would do this really weird work with a cardboard box, or like that particular cover is done on a paper bag. He just whips that stuff out in like five minutes and its just so amazing. We couldn't get Alvin for this record, because he had gone to Europe, so I just kind of went through old magazines and papers and found all the clip art from different ads and stuff. It was a real pain in the ass. (laughs)

AMZ - Will there be a single for this record?

BS - No, no single. That's not something that's gonna happen. We're not setting ourselves up for that, because with commercial radio there are a lot of dollars behind a lot of other bands and we're just not gonna break through that way. We're concentrating more on touring.

AMZ - Do you prefer to play all ages shows generally?

BS - Definitely! Youthful energy is vital to a show. Also, if you play only to the over 21 crowd, you're excluding people. It's not a conscious decision made by the band, but the kids will perceive it that way. We don't want to exclude anyone, so we prefer all ages shows. They're just a lot more fun.

AMZ - Thanks for your time, and good luck with the tour!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

© 1998 by Mary Ellen Gustafson
Web hosting and site design © 1998 DIY Designs