Dead smack in the middle for a rating here on this at
times very pleasant,
but mostly nondescript album . The shame here is that
Ms. Edwards voice
definitely is hit-worthy as well as being a nifty
instrument artistically. It
has enough Trisha Y./ Patti L. twang to be country and
enough Pop lilt to
soar in today's country landscape. But most of the
material here is blase at
best. But to her credit a lot of these songs that do end
up being passable,
would be absolute dreck sung by someone without such an
amazing set of pipes.
" Any Given Moment", " Ready to Fall" , and "A Rose is
a Rose" all have
verses that have a boring, paint-by-numbers sensibility
but are all saved
from being total washouts by very attractive choruses. "
A beautiful Mess" ..
well IS. ( a mess)..it is . country-meets Britney
Spears-meets Ms. Edwards
trenchant, beautiful voice and the result is crap....Ms.
Edwards is far too
mature to be singing immature silliness like this.
But the disc does hold 2 treasures : " Slow Learned" is
a well put-together
kicky hoot and the soaring " This is the Heartache"
could indeed land this
lady on the hit map.
But too much of the time this whole album .. while not
offending.. doesn't
have anything special enough to make you get into
listening to it. The
jolting pop productions of the cuts produced by Richard
Marx juxtaposed with
the songs produced by Country producing legend Keith
Stegall doesn't help out
trying to find anything to aurally grab onto either.
What this girl needs to " Reach" for next time is a
whole lot better songs,
one specific production train of thought and someone
who cares more about
showcasing Ms. Edwards amazing singing chops instead of
trying to throw darts
all over the map to make her sellable. " Reach"
misses. Her voice
definitely doesn't.