You have to hand it to Trent Gardner for bringing together
another stellar cast of musicians for his second "Explorer's Club" effort,
titled, "Raising the Mammoth." Between this project, and the "Leonardo -- The
Absolute Man" album he helmed last year, Gardner has been busy with these side
projects, but he keeps managing to rope his friends in to help out. The usual
suspects, such as Terry Bozzio, James Labrie (Dream Theater) and Gary Wehrkamp
(Shadow Gallery) are here, but this time Gardner also went outside the usual
Magna Carta/prog metal circles to bring in Marty Friedman, the ex-Megadeth axe
slinger, to spice things up.
The result, well, it depends on a number of things, including whether you're
a fan of Gardner's music, whether you're a progressive rock fan in general, and
whether you can handle self-indulgent music, whatever the form may be. If you
don't fit into any of these categories, "Raising the Mammoth" isn't the album
for you.
Then again, even if you do fit all three categories, this disc might
challenge your attention. Even though there are only two official songs on the
disc, Gardner saw fit to assign one track to each shift in the music. Given the
fact that this is, after all, a progressive, experimental side project of an
album, there are plenty of changes going on throughout "Raising the Mammoth." 44
of them, in fact, which makes this one album never to play in "shuffle"
mode.
The two songs are conveniently titled "Raising the Mammoth 1" and "Raising
the Mammoth 2." The former is broken into three section, each of which are
significantly different from one another, as well as distinct from "Raising the
Mammoth 2", essentially yielding 4 different flavors stirred up in Gardner's
musical kitchen. Overall, Gardner has scaled back the metal-edge that marked its
first edition of the "Explorers Club", to feature a more experimental
progressive rock sound. Among the shifting flavors on this, a few things do
remain constant, including Terry Bozzio's solid drum work, and a highly
developed appreciation for the work of one Keith Emerson that is readily
apparent on this disc. Gardner is an admitted fan of Emerson, and "ELP", and it
shows on everything he's done to date, and "Raising the Mammoth" is no
exception.
That said, it really isn't fair to pigeonhole "Explorers Club" into
any one category. For one thing, there isn't any band concept at play on this
disc -- it's just a bunch of great musicians going to town on Trent Gardner's
songwriting. The aforementioned Marty Friedman gets things started on the first
segment, "Passage to Paralysis," with a characteristic, shred-edged solo early
in the song, which describes the protagonist's slide into a mental wasteland, "I'm
lost in my drama's tears/been that way for years/and I can't tell if it's real
or fiction/'cause I can't see the forest for the trees."
"Broad Decay" finds the guy at rock bottom, unable to find hope within
himself, or in the institutions that supposedly exist for our benefit, "Broad
decay, it's all around us/flowing forth in rich abundance/Church and State
combined against us." Set against, Gardner's moody musical landscape, Steve
Walsh's expressive vocals really shine in this piece.
"Vertebrates" brings things to a head, as Gardner and James Labrie trade
vocal lines against a stark acoustic background, "You robbed me of a chance to
engage you on the same page/Now all I bear is lies/No wonder I can't reach you."
The redemption, such that it is, comes with a simple declaration of a guy who is
finally confronting his demons, "I'd like to speak the truth, if you don't
mind/you need to hear this straight, if you don't mind," Once that's out of the
way, the song ends in the type of prog-metal listeners of the first "Explorers
Club" project might have expected when they picked up this album.
The last piece on the disc is longest on the CD, clocking in at easily over
20 minutes of instrumental progressive masturbation. Subtitled "Giganthopiticus"
or, alternately, "Prog-O-Rama," it takes the love-it-or-hate-it nature of this
CD to a whole another level. Fans of prog, or of Gardner might dig this smoothly
shifting experiment in songcraft. The piece features bits recalling the prog
greats of yore -- "Genesis", "Jethro Tull", and "ELP" -- as it weaves in and out
of straight prog, fusion and metal territories. It's meant to be a free-form
exploration of music, and as that it succeeds magnificently. In doing so,
however, Gardner's painted himself into a prog niche that severely restricts
commercial possibilities. "Raising the Mammoth" is a decent album for what it
attempts to do, but it's not one I'd recommend most of my friends to go and pick
up.